Here’s a hard truth: the Philadelphia Eagles' 2025 season was a disaster, and their offense was the biggest culprit. But here's where it gets controversial—was it all Kevin Patullo’s fault, or did the issues run deeper? Let’s dive in.
With the season behind us, we’re breaking down who stays and who goes for 2026. But before we tackle the players, let’s start with the man who called the shots on offense: Offensive Coordinator Kevin Patullo. And this is the part most people miss—his role wasn’t just about playcalling; it was about navigating a perfect storm of challenges.
After winning the Super Bowl in 2024, the Eagles lost Offensive Coordinator Kellen Moore to the New Orleans Saints’ head coaching job. By the time they realized they needed a replacement, the pool of available coordinators had dried up. Left with limited options, the Eagles promoted Patullo, their pass game coordinator since 2021, prioritizing familiarity and continuity. Head Coach Nick Sirianni praised the move, saying, ‘He knows what I’m thinking in certain situations… I trust him with everything.’ But trust alone couldn’t save the Eagles’ offense in 2025.
Here’s the brutal reality: The Eagles’ offense plummeted across the board. From ranking 5th in points per game in 2024 to 19th in 2025, and from 8th in yards per game to 24th, the decline was staggering. Even more shocking? The roster remained largely the same, packed with stars like Jalen Hurts, Saquon Barkley, A.J. Brown, and Lane Johnson. With such talent, finishing in the bottom half of nearly every offensive category was inexcusable.
But it wasn’t just the stats—it was the experience. Watching the Eagles’ offense was like watching a slow-motion train wreck. Predictable playcalling, overly conservative strategies, and head-scratching decisions became the norm. Bold claim: Some of these issues weren’t entirely Patullo’s fault. For instance, Sirianni’s tendency to go ultra-conservative with a lead (think Broncos, Cowboys, and Bills games) or his refusal to push for points at the end of halves were strategic blunders that overshadowed Patullo’s role.
That said, Patullo wasn’t blameless. The offense was plagued by issues that fell squarely on his shoulders: pre-snap penalties, sluggish tempo, and a lack of creative play design. Receivers were rarely schemed open, relying instead on contested catches. Route concepts felt outdated, with an overreliance on hitch routes and four verts. Personnel decisions were baffling, like using Grant Calcaterra as a run-blocking tight end despite it being his weakest skill. Controversial question: Did Patullo’s lack of experience as a coordinator doom him from the start, or was he simply the wrong fit for this roster?
Film analysts and fans alike pointed out these flaws week after week, yet nothing changed. The Eagles stuck to their predictable, uninspired offense, culminating in a playoff loss to the 49ers’ abysmal defense. Here’s the bigger question: Is Patullo’s departure inevitable, or should the Eagles make even bigger changes? While Sirianni’s job is safe, could Jeffrey Lurie and Howie Roseman bring in an offensive guru with the autonomy to overhaul the system—and keep Sirianni out of the way?
Your turn: Do you think Kevin Patullo deserves another shot in 2026, or is it time for a fresh start? Let us know in the comments below. And while you’re at it, follow Jimmy & PhillyVoice on Twitter (@JimmyKempski | @thePhillyVoice) and like us on Facebook (PhillyVoice Sports) for more insights. Don’t forget to add Jimmy’s RSS feed to your reader for all the latest updates!
